Tastes of Lizzy T participates in affiliate advertising programs. We may earn a commission when you make a purchase through links on our site.
You don’t have to give up peanut butter if you’re baking cut out cookies. These peanut butter cut out cookies are soft and hold their shape perfectly when baked. Decorate with your favorite frosting recipe or a simple chocolate ganache.
If you’ve been with us on Instagram lately, you probably know that we’re having a lot of fun with cut out cookies lately. We’ve got puffy cookies, flat cookies, cookies with fancy decorations and details, and cookies with a nice thick layer of buttercream frosting. They’re SO much fun to make, even though stressful at times.
These peanut butter cut out cookies, both simple and cute, don’t require much talent in cookie decorating. They’re soft, slightly chewy, and super addicting. My love of peanut butter and my love of cut out cookies has finally come together in a perfect blend. Plus you have a rich chocolate ganache on top, which makes everything taste better!
The chocolate ganache makes the cookies the absolute best they can be. Without the chocolate, they’re just…peanut butter cookies. I made these cookies for the first time a while ago, just as plain peanut butter cookies. They were good (good enough for me to finish all the scraps in one night!) but nothing SPECTACULAR. Both mom and I knew something was missing.
Although I’d like to say that it was my idea to put the chocolate ganache on top, I’m not that creative. I was thinking something chocolate, but I was thinking of more of a classic buttercream recipe. Mom convinced me that just a layer of rich chocolate would do the trick. Boy, was she right! I can’t say enough about these cookies. They’re just full of peanut butter and chocolate goodness.
In fact, they taste a lot like peanut butter cups to me. What is better than a cute spring cookie that tastes like peanut butter cups?! I’m not really sure, but if there is, it’s something else peanut butter and chocolate. The point is, peanut butter and chocolate is unbeatable!
There are a couple hints about making these cookies:
1. For you crispy cookie lovers, you can bake them to be a little crunchy. To do that, just cook them until they are a little brown on the sides.
2. For those of you who love a soft cookie, you can make them to be a little soft. If you want them soft, DO NOT overbake them. Underbake them a tiny bit if necessary. These cookies will stay soft for quite some time. They are a great freezer cookie. If you just put them in an airtight container, they should stay soft for a few days.
3. Remember that if you’re cutting out a shape that has ends and points, those will bake faster than the middle. An example is like a little Easter bunny. The ears are obviously going to take a shorter time to bake than the middle. So if you’re having trouble baking the middle of the cookies but the ends are getting browner than you want, one thing you can do is lower the temperature of the oven (by maybe 25 degrees) and just bake them a little longer. We’ve had this problem before, because our oven sometimes does not bake evenly and the ends of cookies get brown. I am a sold-out soft cookie fan, so this is a way to prevent hard, crunchy edges.
Do you love peanut butter as much as we do? Find more recipes here!
Chocolate Chip Cut Out Cookies
This recipe is an absolute dream to work with when used with gluten free flour; I could not be happier. I used 280g gluten free flour (and 1tsp xanthan) and followed the rest of the recipe exactly. Usually gluten free dough can be too wet or crumbly, but this rolled and cut out beautifully.
I love the look of cut out cookies but really am not a big fan of the taste. These peanut butter cut out cookies taste great! Thanks so much 🙂
Can I substitute corn syrup for something else
Really wanted to like these but the dough was super finicky even after 2 hours of refrigeration. The finished product tasted just OK, not great. I did not use the ganache, perhaps it would be better with it. The cookie alone though is a no-go for me.
This turned out terrifically! My kiddos really wanted to do their winter cookie cutters but I just don’t like traditional sugar cookies very much (not to mention doing different colored frostings), so I’m glad I found this recipe. The cookies held their shape very well and are not super sweet on their own. They pair perfectly with the ganache! My kiddos didn’t want to wait for the ganache to set so we opted to do a fondue style cookie dipping and we all loved it. 🙂 I baked them on a silpat and they came off without a hitch. I… Read more »
Is the butter used salted or unsalted?
Do you need to use corn syrup ?
Chocolate and peanut butter is my favorite combination! These cookies look delicious. 🙂
Why do sugar cookies get to have all the fun, right? I bet these are amazing with the chocolate ganache!
These are SO fun and I love that they’re peanut butter flavored! These I definitely need to try! 🙂
Such pretty cookies, and, of course, you can’t go wrong with chocolate and peanut butter! 🙂 They would make a nice addition to the food table at a BBQ!
I never make cut out cookies because I don’t like sugar cookies. But pb cut outs??? THAT I can get down with!
Ladies, you outdid yourselves this month – these are some of the most beautiful cookies I have ever seen! Such a winning combination, too with the peanut butter and chocolate. And they’re ALMOST too pretty to eat, but I’d take at least 7. 😉
I’m in love with the chocolate ganache on top! That was a brilliant idea.
Thank goodness these don’t require stellar decorating skills because I’m the worst! Thankfully I can handle pouring ganache and topping with sprinkles. These cookies are adorable. Plus, you say they taste like peanut butter cups and we all know there is very little in the world that’s better than a PB cup!
Oh wow… These might just be the most elegant peanut butter cookies I’ve ever seen! I’d probably be quite happy eating them plain, but that ganache and sprinkle topping looks like it would take them right over the top.