Tastes of Lizzy T participates in affiliate advertising programs. We may earn a commission when you make a purchase through links on our site.
Sweet cream filling between layers of cinnamon infused coffee cake, all topped with a thick, vanilla glaze. This cream filled coffee cake is the breakfast to serve to your guests this season!
Our family spent the end of last week in the gorgeous Ohio Amish country. What’s my favorite part of visiting Amish country? The food, of course! I “oooohhhh” and “aaaahhhh” over the amazing baked goods in all of the Amish bakeries. Really. They know their stuff.
It was about this time a year ago when I walked into an Amish bakery and immediately spied this delectable two-layer coffee cake with white cream stuffed inside. After calling Maddie to hurry over and check it out, we decided that cake had to happen in our kitchen. Fast forward to one year later. Yes, it took me that long to make this Cream Filled Coffee Cake. So sad, but time flies as I’m sure you all understand.
Part of the reason it took me so long to make this cake was because I didn’t have a recipe. I knew I could create one, possibly from these muffins or this coffee cake with not much of a problem. And then I happened to be walking through a second-hand store, looking at the cookbooks and spied an old church cookbook from Berlin, Ohio, filled with classic Amish recipes. You’ll never guess what I found?
Yes, the recipe for this gorgeous cream-filled coffee cake! After I found the recipe, I made it immediately. That year was worth the wait. This cake is amazing. The cinnamon streusel layered with a thick, biscuit-like cake, the sweet cream filling oozing from the middle and the vanilla glaze drizzled on top all make this cake a showstopper. We made it and shared it with all of our church friends. Thankfully they help us eat these desserts so we don’t eat them all ourselves.
Although there are several different layers and steps to the recipe, don’t get scared off. You’ll mix up the batter and the topping separately and layer it in two 8″ round pans that have been sprayed with cooking spray. The layers will be cake batter, cinnamon topping, cake batter, cinnamon topping. You’ll end up with two layers of these nice, tall coffee cakes after baking. Remove them from the pans immediately after baking. Don’t worry if a little of the cake sticks to the pan. We had a corner stick but we just removed that piece of cake from the pan, put it where it belonged in the cake and no one knew the difference. The perfectionist in me hates it when cakes stick to pans, but the realist in me knows that in the end, no one really notices. Or they don’t care if they do notice, because the cake is just that good.
While the cakes are baking you can make the cream filling. You’ll beat two egg whites until they are bubbly and frothy. Don’t worry about getting the egg whites stiff like meringue. You just want them to be bubbly and well-whisked. It took about 2-3 minutes in the stand mixer to get our eggs frothy. Transfer those eggs to another bowl and then beat the butter until it is almost white in color. Then you’ll add the eggs to the butter, along with the powdered sugar and vanilla. Beat the frosting for an additional 2-3 minutes until it has a nice consistency and is fluffy.
Spread that cream filling in between the two layers of cake. Then take a minute to whip up the glaze. This glaze will be thick. We like to use heavy cream to give it a rich flavor. If you use regular milk, your glaze will be just a bit runnier, but will still taste so delightful. Drizzle that vanilla glaze on top to give the cake a pretty finish.
With Thanksgiving coming, this is definitely a cake to serve to guests on Thanksgiving morning. You’ll get smiles bright and early as they enjoy this sweet cinnamon cake with a cup of coffee. And it will be the perfect thing to keep their bellies satisfied while that turkey bakes!