Tastes of Lizzy T participates in affiliate advertising programs. We may earn a commission when you make a purchase through links on our site.
These lightly sweetened Italian Easter Bread Rolls rise beautifully and boast a lovely golden brown color. A perfect way to display Easter eggs!
About two years ago during the spring & Easter season, I happened upon Italian Easter Bread recipe. It was shortly after we had come across this Egg Twist Bread in an old recipe book. We quickly fell in love with that bread recipe and when I saw this Easter bread, I know that bread would be perfect for pairing with a decorated Easter egg. Colorful….pretty…unique….just what everyone wants on their Easter dinner table alongside potatoes and ham.
So Maddie and I set out to make that bread in a beautiful twisted circle with a dyed Easter egg on top.
And the bread tasted delicious. But the bread did not look as beautiful as it tasted. The dye from the egg ended up sweating all over the bread during the baking process. Which resulted in something like this:
Still delicious, but not very pretty, right? We tried different techniques and different dyes an embarrassing amount of times in order to combat this problem. Which led to another problem of eating entirely too much sweet Italian Easter Bread. Which is embarrassing in a completely different way.
So two years ago we spent all Easter season with pink and purple fingers from coloring Easter eggs (which the kids did not mind at all) and colorful sprinkles dotting our kitchen floor from making and eating Italian Easter Bread. But we never shared that recipe with you, our faithful readers, because I just wasn’t happy with the looks.
Here we stand, two years later, with a simple solution that makes me wonder why in the world we didn’t think of it two years ago. Sometimes it takes forever for a lightbulb to go off.
Soft, twisted bread dough baked to a golden brown with a dyed Easter egg placed in the center of the ring after it bakes. No dye all over the dough as it rises, which makes a beautiful homemade roll.
For this recipe I used Bob’s Red Mill Organic Unbleached All Purpose White Flour. It’s a high protein flour that produces well-textured baked good and allows dough to rise beautifully. Think fluffy and light. It’s versatile and can be used in all of your cooking and baking. Bob’s Red Mill makes some of my favorite flours (coconut and almond, anyone?), plus chia and flax seeds for all of your healthy baking needs.
This homemade bread dough is soft and easy to work with. You can use a stand mixer with the dough hook to knead it, but because it is so easy to work with, I often like to make this bread without a mixer. Good old fashioned kneading by hand. I know…I’m so retro.
Mix up and knead your dough, being careful not to add too much flour. You’ll want the dough to be a little sticky, but not so sticky that it sticks to your fingers.
Allow the dough to rise until double, then split it into 20 pieces. Roll each piece of dough into a rope. Twist two ropes together, then form a ring and pinch the ends together to seal.
My favorite part of these lightly sweetened rolls is their pretty golden brown color. To get that look you brush the tops with a whisked egg before the second rise. You can also sprinkle some nonpareils on top. They’ll stick to the egg wash nicely.
Allow the rolls to rise once more, then bake at 350 degrees for 15 minutes or until they are golden brown.
This is one of the easiest homemade bread recipes I’ve ever made. They turn out fluffy and golden brown every.single.time.
My kids go crazy for these simple Italian Easter Bread Rolls. They can smell this bread baking from a mile away! They love devouring it and I love making their spring day just a little happier.
Hi, I made these yesterday and they turned out AWESOME! Your instructions and photos were really hellpful! I have never made a braided bread before and feel a great sense of accomplishment. Thanks sooooo much! (I made these without the boiled eggss on top)
Italian Easter Bread Rolls Recipe is marvelous! Was easier to make than I thought it would be. My “nests” turned out beautifully. Each one of my children and grandchildren received one for this Easter. Will certainly be making these again. Thank you so much for sharing this recipe. It’s a keeper for me!
Hi ,i did the dough about an hour ago and it doesn’t seem to be rising much.
Covered it well and put in oven with the light on,no heat of course.Used instant yeast 2 and 1 /4 teaspoon.
What could be wrong?
i made this yesterday and it was SUPERB. Followed the recipe to a T and it came out perfect. i made 1 ring and cooked it for 25 min. i recommend this recipes to anyone.
which i could attach the picture, i came out beautifully.
So— very confusing regarding the # of eggs used in dough. Is it THREE plus one held out to brush on rolls? Or— TWO used in dough, with 3rd for brushing?
Thanks for all.
This looks delicious!
I have a small family, so would it be possible to freeze half the batch after making it? How would you go about that and how would you bake it after it thaws?
Also, how many days do these stay fresh for and how do you recommend keeping them fresh? In a ziplock, in the fridge, etc. Obviously I don’t bake very often lol, but I want to start!
I tried making these because they look so good but could never get the yeast to proof. I threw out the milk/salt/yeast twice. My yeast is good as I use it almost every day for bread and I measured the temperature with a thermometer. Doesn’t adding the salt up front kill the yeast?
could you just make a loaf out of this?
I just made these for tomorrow’s Easter dinner. My house smells like heaven. They came out perfect. I was able to steal a little nibble and they’re soooooo good. I can’t wait to serve them yo my family. I’ll be keeping this recipe.
Can I use bread flour?? Or is all purpose flour better??? I cant find the one you call for and I am doing this today!!
My dough and rolls turned out amazing! They are so pretty and the rolls taste so good! I used raw, dyed eggs and they did not hard boil. The whites were runny after baking and removing from the rolls. Any suggestions on cooking the eggs completely? Also, I dyed raw eggs and put them in the fridge for several hours before adding them to the rolls and baking. I brushed the rolls with the egg wash and waited 30 minutes before tucking the eggs into the dough. I had no bleeding of the egg dye. I just need to figure… Read more »
Well I just watched the video and answered my own question about shaping the circle lol! But, still want to know if I can use instant yeast. Thanks! I’ve been wanting to make these for years.
If I want to bake them in the morning, do I put them in the fridge the night before after the first or second rise? Thanks!
can you make the dough the night before and bake the next day?
Made these today. The dough was fabulous to work with! They came out perfect. So soft and tender and delicious! Thank you for the recipe!