Tastes of Lizzy T participates in affiliate advertising programs. We may earn a commission when you make a purchase through links on our site.
My Grandma’s Thanksgiving Turkey Stuffing has stood the test of time. This buttery, savory, melt-in-your-mouth stuffing is the best stuffing recipe around!
Stuffing….or dressing? Which is it in your house? What is the difference between the two?
It’s simple…stuffing is “stuffed” inside the bird. Dressing is usually baked on the side. My mom usually stuffs the turkey. I usually stuff the turkey AND bake dressing on the side.
Call this recipe whichever you’d like and bake it whichever way you prefer. You’ll love this best turkey dressing or homemade stuffing recipe either way!
Are you all so excited that Thanksgiving is almost here? I think I love Thanksgiving more than Christmas. And one reason why? The food, of course! It’s all about the corn casserole, mashed potatoes and pumpkin pie.
Today we are sharing with you one of our classic family recipes that without fail, ends up on our Thanksgiving menu: Grandma’s Thanksgiving Turkey Stuffing.
This recipe was my Grandma’s classic stuffing recipe and was passed down to my mom. I grew up enjoying this savory traditional stuffing recipe, and now my kids are enjoying the tradition, too!
Our recipe has just a few key seasonings: poultry seasoning, salt and black pepper. You’ll also get flavor from the butter, onion, celery and chicken stock, but for the most part, all that savory flavor comes from poultry seasoning.
We use a pre-mixed poultry seasoning that you can buy in the spice aisle at the grocery store. You can mix your own if you’d like. It generally has sage, rosemary, thyme, marjoram, a touch of nutmeg and black pepper.
If you’ve never made Thanksgiving turkey stuffing before, you may think it is difficult. Our recipe is very simple, though and calls for just a handful ingredients: bread, butter, onion, celery, chicken broth, eggs and spices.
We say to use 13-15 cups of bread cubes. Make sure the bread cubes are tightly packed into the cup. Don’t drop them in so there is a lot of air around them, but press them down into the cup. This will help make sure you have enough bread to soak up the liquid. If you like a drier stuffing, use more bread cubes.
Pour this mixture over the dry bread cubes, then add the chicken stock, eggs and spices.
Why add eggs to bread stuffing? Many of you have asked this question. The main reason is because my grandma did it, my mom continued making stuffing this way, and there is just no better stuffing. 🙂 Simple, right?
I’ve never not put eggs in stuffing, but also, the eggs act as a bit of a binder. They prevent the stuffing from being crumbly.
Here’s my answer: Do what you’d like.
Are both methods safe?
Yes. If you stuff a turkey with bread stuffing, make sure the center of the stuffing cooks to 165 degrees Fahrenheit. You’ll need a long thermometer to go through the turkey and test it. But it is safe to eat if cooked to the correct temperature.
Our Thermoworks ThermaPen tests the internal temperatures of meats, breads and cakes INSTANTLY. This instant-read thermometer is AMAZING. Get it here.
I like both stuffed turkeys and unstuffed. I prefer my stuffing just a little crispier, so cooking it in a casserole dish allows the top of the bread to get a little toasty. And who doesn’t like herbed, buttered, toasted bread?!
For food safety guidelines as far as stuffing the turkey, you can read some info from the USDA here.
It’s important to spoon the stuffing into the turkey loosely. You don’t want to pack it in. Plan about ¾ cup of stuffing per 1 pound of turkey.
For food safety reasons, stuff the turkey immediately before you place it in the oven. Have the oven preheated and ready to go. Stuff the turkey, then pop it in the oven.
This recipe also works well in the slow cooker. Spray the slow cooker with cooking spray, then add the bread cube mixture. Cover and cook on low for about 6-8 hours. Check the internal temperature to make sure it cooks through.
This will help save space for the rest of your Thanksgiving meal.
I hope you enjoy this Thanksgiving turkey stuffing recipe as much as my family has over the past decades. Just read the reviews below to see how many people have loved this! It’s continually one of our most popular holiday recipes and we thank you for that.
Q: Do you have a recipe that has stood the test of time?
My Mother passed a few years ago. Although she showed me many times how to make her Thanksgiving dressing, I was never able to recreate her holiday magic. She was the type of cook who didn’t have a recipe, she just added what she thought the dish needed. I found your recipe last year and literally cried when I tasted my Mom’s dressing. Thank you so much for sharing your Grandma’s recipe. I make a double batch to make sure we have plenty for leftovers! As a side note, I don’t stuff the bird or put it in the oven.… Read more »
This is nearly my EXACT recipe…old timer’s favorite. The only ingredient not listed here that I use is…..a tiny itty bitty smidgen of Allspice. Yes, allspice. Not enough to overpower the dish but JUST enough to lend a warm nutty aroma and with the onions and celery scents, the allspice smells like you have never smelled it before. It’s amazing and my stuffing is one of the top reasons why my husband married me (or so he tells me).
Wouldn’t the drippings from the turkey be a better substitute for chicken broth?
can you prepare this a day ahead?
This is like my mom’s too except she mixed regular bread and cornbread. She also added sage seasoning.
This recipe is similar to mine and hubby loves it. We make a ton of it so we have enough to stuff the bird and do some in the crockpot
We were feeling crazy one year and added dried cranberries and cashews. OMG you can’t believe how yummy it was, a little bit of sweet, salty and savory!
I cook the gizzard, heart and neck to make the broth. Than I chop up heart and gizzard for dressing. I don’t use butter, I cook sausage and then remove from pan and cook celery and onion in grease. I use poultry seasoning and sage. My stuffing is very moist before cooking or stuffing turkey. I use white bread. No salt.
Can you put this dressing in the crockpot
My mother in law gave me this recipe the first year Rick and I were married. She didn’t even have it written down but was able to come up with the amounts for an 8 lb turkey. Over the years our turkey size has increased to…..as big as we can get! And I just keep increasing the dressing amounts. The original recipe in her handwriting is stained and worn but we love it. It has been passed on to all 3 of our kids.
This recipe was an experiment, a trial run for me to see if I could make and freeze it to bake on Thanksgiving. This stuffing is delicious and so easy to make! After doing some research online, I made the stuffing exactly as stated, put it in a greased foil pan, let it cool and wrapped it tightly with foil. After two weeks, I removed the pan from the freezer and popped it straight in a 350 degree oven with the foil on. I baked it for an hour and 15 minutes. I then took the foil off and increased… Read more »
I ran out of casserole dishes so ended up putting the mixture into a muffin tray instead. Worked a treat because it made the edges all crispy and made for easy individual serves!
This sounds yummy! I’m going to cook my turkey thighs on top of the stuffing.(I don’t like white meat) Have a great Thanksgiving!
What to do I like my stuffing moist
This looks to be the recipe of my grandmothers that I unfortunately misplaced, however couple changes that would follow her recipe. One, I separate the eggs and mix the yolks in with the spices and add to the bread cubes after I’ve let the turkey broth soak into the bread for a bit. I also boil my celery and onion and drain then add in to my egg and seasoning mixture. Her recipe called to take the egg whites and with a fork fluff till they just got frothy. This makes the dressing fluff up in the oven and is… Read more »
i make stuffing like my mom did I make it for 2 20lb turkeys and extra pan for the oven. I use 2 1/2 loaves of white bread. I toast it and then cut it into little cubes. I also use 1 1/2 stalks of celery., and 5 to 6 large onions sauteed in butter. I add about 8 eggs and mix till it is all moistened and soft. also use Thyme and poultry seasoning,chicken broth,salt and pepper. . i stuff the birds just before roasting the turkey . Then with extra stuffing in a pan, sprinkle with chicken broth… Read more »