Hints on how to get the thickest, softest, bakery style sugar cookies. It’s the best sugar cookie recipe around! If you love sugar cookies, see all of our recipes here.
Bakery Style Sugar Cookies Recipe
You’re about to meet the best little sugar cookie your hands will ever hold. They hold true to the same characteristics of our bakery-style chocolate chip cookies: thick, lightly crisp around the edges, but oh, so soft and chewy in the middle.
Our sugar cookies might look like an average cookie, but today we’re sharing a few hints with you on how to make the best sugar cookie. A sugar cookie that is anything but average.
Let me tell you how these came to be.
Last summer I was set on creating a cookie that I couldn’t resist. I’m a little picky about my cookies. If I’m going to eat a cookie, I want it to be worth eating (sound familiar?). While the kids were away at camp, I set my goal of the week to create the best tasting sugar cookie. No kids is the perfect time for cookie testing. Cookie dough all for me! 🙂
I started with this chewy sugar cookie recipe and adapted it just a tad to give it unbelievable taste and texture. Yes, the recipe itself is extremely important, but the technique and ingredients are what you want to pay close attention to here.
How to Make Sugar Cookies
To start, you’ll make a sugar cookie dough just like you would any other cookie dough. Add the ingredients into a stand mixer and mix them well. There are a couple of key ingredients that you’ll want to note.
The first is the flavoring that we use. What gives these Bakery Style Sugar Cookies such a uniquely fresh taste is LorAnn’s Princess Cake & Cookie Bakery Emulsion. You can find this emulsion on Amazon, or in your local Hobby Lobby and sometimes even Walmart. It is described as “light and nutty” with “citrus and vanilla undertones”. Since most everyone uses vanilla in cookie recipes, this water-based emulsion gives a different taste that everyone loves. I am always asked what kind of flavoring I use in these cookies and today I’m giving away that secret.
You’ll notice that the emulsion has a hint of citrus. I also add in a touch of lemon juice. Don’t worry…the cookies are not going to be overpowering with lemon flavor. It’s just a subtle, bright, fresh flavor.
How to Make Thick Cookies
Lemon Sugar Cookies with Glaze
Our second ingredient secret is actually a new addition to our cookie. A few weeks ago I got the opportunity to test Land O’Lakes new European-style butter. I’m usually a skeptic when it comes to name brand ingredients being better than store-brand, but let me tell you. Land O’Lakes made a believer out of me with their new European butter. It is churned with sweet cream and has a higher milk fat content which creates cookies that are unbelievably thick and rich.
Oh, and Land O’Lakes is not paying me to say this. They simply sent me 4 sticks of butter. One batch of cookies later and I was a believer.
Don’t just take my word for it. Let me show you the difference.
The cookies on the right are made with regular butter. Delicious? Yes…but they are flat. This is how we’ve made our cookies the past year and everyone has loved them.
The cookies on the left are made with European style butter. The difference is obvious. If you like thick, chewy, rich cookies, this is the butter you’re going to want to buy.
I will always use European style butter now in my cookies.
Let me quickly walk you through the technique of making the cookies. You’ll see that our method is similar to our other bakery style cookies.
- Scoop the dough with a large ice cream scoop and place the dough balls on a non stick baking sheet.
- Press them lightly with a glass that has been dipped in sugar.
- Pop these pans of cookies into the fridge for at least an hour.
- Brush the tops of the cookies with a bit of homemade buttermilk, made simply with heavy cream and vinegar. Don’t skip this step. This little tricks makes the top of your cookies just perfect.
- Sprinkle more sugar on top. Use colored sprinkles if you’d like. Perfect for showing team spirit!
- Bake the cookies at 375 for 9-10 minutes. Don’t overbake them. Taking the cookies out just before they turn brown ensures that the cookies will be soft and chewy for days. If you can resist eating them, that is!
If you follow all of these steps closely, you’ll end up with cookies that will rival the best of bakery cookies.
Q: We’ve shared some things that make the perfect sugar cookie for us. What is your ideal sugar cookie?
OTHER SUGAR COOKIE RECIPES
- Chewy Sugar Cookies
- Chai Spiced Sugar Cookies
- Lofthouse Style Sugar Cookies
- Lemon Sugar Cookies
- Cream Cheese Sugar Cookies
- Cut Out Sugar Cookies
- Almond Sugar Cookies
- Refrigerated Sugar Cookies
Bakery Style Sugar Cookies
Ingredients
- 2 3/4 cups all purpose flour
- 1 teaspoon baking soda
- 1/2 teaspoon baking powder
- 1 cup European style butter, softened
- 1 1/2 cups white granulated sugar
- 1 large egg
- 3/4 teaspoon LorAnn Princess Cake & Cookie Bakery Emulsion
- 1/2 tablespoon lemon juice
- 1/4 cup heavy cream
- 3/4 teaspoon white vinegar
- Extra sugar for sprinkling on top
Instructions
- In a small bowl, stir together flour, baking soda, and baking powder. Set aside.
- In a large mixing bowl, cream together butter and sugar until smooth. Beat in the egg, Princess emulsion and juice. Gradually blend in dry ingredients.
- Scoop the dough into about 18 1-1/2" inch balls and place on an ungreased cookie sheet. Slightly flatten the top of each cookie with the bottom of a glass that has been dipped in sugar.
- Refrigerate the cookies for at least 1 hour.
- In a small bowl, combine the heavy cream and vinegar. This mixture will get very thick and curdle. Use a pastry brush to brush this mixture on top of the cookies.
- Sprinkle the top of the cookies with extra granulated sugar or sprinkles.
- Bake at 375 degrees for 10 minutes, removing the cookies just before the edges get brown.
- Allow the cookies to cool for 5 minutes, then move them to a flat surface to cool.
- Store in an airtight container.
Nutrition
Carol says
Well, these look good . Where are we supposed to get the European butter and the cake and coolie bakery emulsion? I don’t think I have ever seen it in our grocery stores. We have a pretty darn good grocery store and they do carry a lot of butters etc. this dough doesn’t look like it could be rolled out and used with a cookie cutter and is it a moist cookie?
Thanks
Julie Clark says
Carol, You can get the bakery emulsion on Amazon (there’s a link in the post) or our Hobby Lobby, craft store and sometimes even Walmart has it. At Walmart it is in the cake decorating section (by the bridal). You can find European butter in the grocery store, right where all of the butter is. I’ve tried rolling out this recipe and it spreads too much…the shapes don’t hold. Yes, it is moist! 🙂
Kelli's Kitchen says
I have learned so much! Not only will I be buying the butter (as soon as I find it at the store) but the emulsion too! Thanks for all the tips. Scheduled for FaceBook
GiGi Eats says
When i could eat sweets — SUGAR COOKIES were my go-to for sure!!!!
Julie @ Julie's Eats & Treats says
European butter you don’t say? I have got to try this because they cookies look amazing!
Isabelle @ Crumb says
Thank you for risking your waistline and your tastebuds to come up with the perfect recipe… it definitely looks like you succeeded. Isn’t it amazing how a small change like the kind of butter you use totally changes the results? I’ve turned into a total butter snob ever since I discovered a high-quality European butter that my local Costco carries. Now I just need to figure out where I can track down this magical emulsion!
Laurie says
Hey,
I made this recipe this weekend and they are yummy but I think they lack some taste. I didn’t have the LorAnn Princess Cake & Cookie Bakery Emulsion, though I did have that same emulsion but I had the Buttery Sweet Dough Flavor from LorAnn so I used that and a little bit of vanilla.
I’m from Belgium, so I guess I have European style butter. My cookies don’t really look the same though, they are thick but the top looks different. Will make them again with some more flavoring, maybe some of my measurements were off, really don’t like working with cups (whoops)
http://i1050.photobucket.com/albums/s401/LollieLaurie/IMG_20150914_091400.jpg
Julie Clark says
Hi there, Laurie! I definitely think the princess cake and cookie emulsion is a must for flavor. It has such a light, fresh taste that I just love. Much lighter than butter flavoring. I’m not sure if all butter where you are is European butter. Ours is specifically named that, but it does have a high milk fat content so maybe you can check that. It also looks like you cooked them longer than I do. If you like a crisper cookie, that’s totally fine, but we like ours to be softer and take them out before they turn brown. Thanks so much for sharing your pic!
Barbara Noland says
Can you use this recipe to bake a smaller cookie (in size)? sounds delicious….already ordered the bakery oil
Julie Clark says
Yes! They just won’t take as long to cook.
Diane Quick says
If you freeze these cookies, do you let them thaw completely like you do the chocolate chip cookies?
Julie Clark says
Do you mean the cookie dough? or the baked cookies? If I freeze cookie dough, I usually let it defrost in the fridge so that the dough is cold, but not frozen when I bake it. If I freeze the cookies, let the cookies completely thaw before opening the container so that the moisture and freshness stays in. 🙂 I hope that helps!
Marisela Flores says
If I’m going to freeze the raw dough….do I still brush with the buttermilk prior to freezing? Or do I wait until they are thawed and before I bake them?
Thanks!!!
Julie Clark says
I usually wait until they are thawed before brushing with buttermilk.
Heartprintlady says
I made these today. Wonderful! I substituted some things. Forgot we were out of granulated sugar so I used powdered sugar instead. Used margarine, but did not add salt. Did not have the emulsion so doubled the Vanilla. Instead of the cream, regular milk with the vinegar to brush on. and did have enough granulated sugar to sprinkle. Did not chill dough. Turned out A+++++++ Real Bakery Stylesugar Cookies. Thanks this recipe is a keeper and The best one I happened upon so far ever!!!
Julie Clark says
Awesome! And thanks for the substitution hints!
Diane says
The cookies tasted great. They were a little flat though. What did I do wrong?
Julie Clark says
What type of butter did you use? This recipe showcases the cookies with European butter, which has a higher fat content and makes the cookies thicker.
Diane says
I used Lurpak, a Danish butter.
Diane says
I’m going to try these cookies again with a different brand European butter. I cant find the brand you used in my area. Also, what is the purpose of the buttermilk on top of the cookie? I’ve never seen that before.
Julie Clark says
It just gives it a little bit of extra flavor and texture on top. We’ve left it off before, so feel free to do that.
Beth says
Do you have a similar recipe that I can use to make cut out cookies? I see an earlier comment that this recipe wouldn’t work well for cutouts as they spread. Thanks!
Julie Clark says
Here are two of our favorites: https://www.tastesoflizzyt.com/cream-cheese-sugar-cookies/ and https://www.tastesoflizzyt.com/gender-reveal-cookies-recipe/
Holly says
This recipe looks very good…I’m going to make them for Christmas. I’m not much on lemon in my sugar cookies, what can I substitute for the lemon juice? More of the emulsion or vanilla extract?
Julie Clark says
If you can use something slightly acidic, that would be good. I don’t really think you’ll taste the lemon juice much, but replacing it for a touch of orange juice or something would be good. You might just be able to leave it out, but we haven’t tried that.
John says
Followed the recipe to the T and I can honestly say that these are the BEST sugar cookies I have EVER ate!!! One of my pet peeves is folks who change a recipe and then blame the inevitable results on the recipe! Made several batches for family and friends and now they all call me the sugar cookie king!!!
Thanks
Julie Clark says
Wow!! Thank you!
Emily says
Eeks! Just started mixing. Is your butter salted? Do you add any other salt? My butter is not salted.
Julie Clark says
I do use salted butter. I’d add a pinch or so. Maybe 1/4 teaspoon.
Diane Largay says
They sound delicious! Is butter from Ireland ok? I believe it has a higher fat content!
Julie Clark says
I’ve seen that and I think it would work but haven’t tried it. Thank you!
Tina says
can you use regular buttermilk? I have it on hand but not heavy cream….
Julie Clark says
Yes!