Julie Clark
Posted:
20 Pie Recipes That Are Must-Tries This Thanksgiving
May contain affiliate links. Disclosure policy.
20 Thanksgiving pie recipes including cream, fruit, custard, and more. Find your perfect holiday dessert to complete the festive table.
Thanksgiving is quickly approaching, and it’s time to plan your Thanksgiving menu! This week, we’ve put together a collection of our favorite pie recipes for the holidays. Whether you love traditional pie or want to try something new, you’ll find something you’ll love here. Check out these recipes to make the perfect oatmeal pie crust and graham cracker pie crust!
Get a new pretty pie plate for the holidays! I love a white scalloped pie plate.
1
Grandma’s Pie Crust
Buttery, flakey pie crust is the foundation for the very best pie recipes. It only takes a few minutes to prepare and beats store-bought crust every time!
GET RECIPE >
2
Apple Butter Pie
Use homemade apple butter to make this incredible Apple Butter Pie. It's smooth and rich with warm fall spices and is a great alternative to traditional pumpkin pie.
GET RECIPE >
3
Oatmeal Pie
This old-fashioned Amish pie recipe with flavors similar to pecan pie. It's the perfect allergy-friendly alternative for family gatherings!
GET RECIPE >
4
Amish Buttermilk Pie
This traditional Amish pie is almost 100 years old! It's a smooth custard pie made with tangy buttermilk. Pair it with fresh berries and a dollop of homemade whipped cream.
GET RECIPE >
5
Banana Cream Pie
100% Homemade Banana Cream Pie – no pudding mix needed! This pie is made with whole ingredients that you likely have on hand in your pantry.
GET RECIPE >
6
Coconut Cream Pie
The very best homemade Coconut Cream Pie with toasted coconut, custard base, and whipped topping. Perfect for quick no-bake dessert needs!
GET RECIPE >
7
Pecan Pie
Classic Pecan Pie with a buttery brown sugar and pecan filling. They are easy to make ahead of time and have a beautiful presentation for the holidays!
GET RECIPE >
8
Apple Pie
The best homemade apple pie recipe with nutmeg and cinnamon! Serve with a scoop of vanilla ice cream and caramel sauce. ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ Reader Thuy says, “This is it! Your search for the best apple pie is over! It was delicious! I strongly suggest you to use a 9-inch baking dish. I had a 9.5 and I couldn’t seal the pie very well. Definitely buying a 9-inch dish just for this pie!”
GET RECIPE >
9
Butternut Squash Pie
Lightly sweetened Butternut Squash Pie in a gingerbread crust. It is similar to sweet potato and pumpkin pies with a sweet, nutty flavor. Another great alternative to pumpkin pie!
GET RECIPE >
10
Grandma’s Sour Cherry Pie
This easy pie recipe only has 4 ingredients in the filling and is one of my favorite pies of all time! It's perfectly sweet and tart, using canned tart cherries.
GET RECIPE >
11
Pear Cranberry Pie
Pear Cranberry Pie is a great non-traditional pie to serve at Thanksgiving! It has tartness from the cranberries and a fresh, sweet flavor from the pears. Be creative with styling the top crust with lattice or double crust!
GET RECIPE >
12
Homemade Custard Pie
Creamy custard pie is hard to beat! Use scalded milk to create the best flavor.
GET RECIPE >
13
Blueberry Blackberry Pie Recipe
Flavorful Blueberry Blackberry Pie is sweet, tart and bursting with fruit. Check out the secret ingredients in this recipe that take this pie to the next level.
GET RECIPE >
14
Peanut Butter Pudding Pie
This pie is easy and great for when ingredients are running low. With just 5 pantry staples and 20 minutes of prep, this pie is perfect for when you're in a pinch.
GET RECIPE >
15
Coconut Custard Pie
Coconut Custard Pie only requires 6 ingredients and 10 minutes in the oven! It's the perfect blend between our coconut cream pie and custard pie recipes.
GET RECIPE >
16
Chocolate Chip Funny Cake Pie
This old recipe stands the test of time! It's chocolatey, rich, and unique. With layers of pie crust, chocolate, and cake mix, it will redefine what a pie is to you!
GET RECIPE >
17
Pineapple Pie
Creamy, custard-like filling with crushed pineapple. This cake takes incredibly little time to make, with just 10 minutes of prep and 15 minutes of cook time!
GET RECIPE >
18
Cinnamon Roll Apple Pie
Ever thought of using canned cinnamon rolls as a pie crust? This Cinnamon Roll Apple Pie elevates apple pie to new heights. It's sweet, flakey, and tastes absolutely incredible.
GET RECIPE >
19
Sweet Potato Pie
Making Sweet Potato Pie with vanilla pudding mix creates the most amazing flavor and texture! Use canned sweet potatoes to speed up the process if you'd like.
GET RECIPE >
20
Pumpkin Pie
America's favorite Thanksgiving pie! This traditional Pumpkin Pie recipe is foolproof, making this a holiday staple.
GET RECIPE >
