Oven Baked Potatoes {Steakhouse Copycat}

Table of Contents
  1. What are the best potatoes for baking?
  2. What is the best way to bake a potato?
  3. Watch us Make Oven Baked Potatoes
  4. Frequently Asked Questions
  5. What’s the Best Baked Potato Recipe?
  6. Oven Baked Potatoes {Steakhouse Copycat} Recipe
  7. Baked Potato Toppings
  8. Other Potato Recipes

Wondering how restaurants get those perfect potatoes? Here’s the hints on how to make the best oven baked potatoes with salty, crispy skin and fluffy potato inside. 

Does your family love potatoes? Mine will take them any way they can get them: stuffed potatoes, cheesy potatoes, roasted potatoes…even sweet potatoes. If oven baked potatoes are for dinner, they’re 100% all in.

how long to bake a potato in the oven

How did your mom bake potatoes when you were growing up? I honestly can’t remember how my mom did, but I know that when I first got married, if I wanted a baked potato, I’d take the easy route and throw them in the microwave.

Now potatoes are good any time and with just about any main dish recipe, but microwaving a baked potato can lead to dry potato skin and even a dry potato inside if you cook it too long.

As we started visiting several steakhouses that served amazing, crispy, salted skin potatoes, I knew I had to figure out how to get that same flavor and texture at home.

We’ve made baked potatoes in the air fryer, but what about the perfect baked potato in the oven?

We’re talking the best baked potato recipe here today that takes just 5 minutes prep time and yes, a little longer to bake than the microwave, but so totally worth it.

What are the best potatoes for baking?

To start, you need to choose the best type of potato. As you remember from our ultimate potato guide that we shared last year, Russet potatoes are the best for baking. They are a high starch potato that when baked, lend a light, mealy texture.

potatoes sitting on a cutting board

What is the best way to bake a potato?

If you love the restaurant-style, crispy skin potatoes, here’s how you get it.

  • Scrub the potatoes to get off any dirt, then dry them.
  • Pierce the potato 2-3 times with a fork or a small paring knife.
  • Rub olive oil all over the outside of the potatoes.
  • Rub salt (or salt and pepper) on the outside of the potatoes. Be generous with both the oil and the salt. It’s what gives the potatoes that amazing flavor and makes you want to eat the skin.
  • Place the potatoes on a baking sheet (line with parchment paper for easy cleanup) and bake in a preheated oven (425ºF) for about 50 minutes. We put our pan on the middle oven rack. The exact timing will depend on how large the potato is.

Pro Tip

If you are fixing bacon as a topping, cook it in advance and rub bacon grease on the outside of the potato rather than oil. It’s amazing!

An alternative is to use coconut oil or butter for rubbing on the outside. Each fat gives just a little bit of a different flavor. Try several to find which one your family likes best.

Watch us Make Oven Baked Potatoes

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it better to bake potatoes in aluminum foil?

You will often see recipes for wrapping a potato in foil. Although this works, we don’t believe this is best. The potato actually gets u0022steamedu0022 and the skin will not get crispy if it is baked wrapped in foil. For that reason, we say no foil is best!

Do I have to poke potatoes before baking?

The purpose behind piercing a potato with a fork is to let the steam escape and prevent the potatoes from exploding while baking. I’ll be honest that I don’t always poke the potatoes before I bake them. I’ve never had a potato explode on me. But…for safety, I do recommend piercing the potatoes.

What goes good with baked potatoes?

This baked potato recipe goes great with just about any main dish, but we especially love potatoes with ham, roast beef, pulled pork and steak.

How Long do I Bake a Potato in the oven?

I like to bake potatoes at 425ºF. It generally takes a large Russet potato about 45 minutes to become tender, but the exact timing will depend on how large the potato is. And testing the potatoes is when I do pierce them with a fork. Poke the potato with a fork to ensure that the potato is soft inside.

What should the internal temperature of a baked potato be?

According to the Idaho Potato Commission, the perfect baked potato will be 210º Fahrenheit inside.

Are baked potatoes healthy?

Roasted potatoes are not low in carbs, but they are a natural food so are a great option, especially for those who lead active lifestyles. Be sure to eat the skin where most of the vitamins and minerals are.

What’s the Best Baked Potato Recipe?

You’ll find that just below. Because of the flavor of the olive oil and salt, I’m happy just topping the baked potato with butter and a little bit of fresh parsley, but when I’m feelin’ crazy? Serve with sour cream, cheddar cheese, chives and bacon for the most delicious loaded baked potatoes.

Want to air fry potatoes? They’re amazing. Try our recipe.

baked potato on a plate with a fork
baked potato on a plate with a fork

Oven Baked Potatoes {Steakhouse Copycat}

4.89 from 85 votes
Wondering how restaurants get those perfect potatoes? Here’s the hints on how to make the best oven baked potatoes with salty, crispy skin and fluffy potato inside. 
Servings 4
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 45 minutes
Total Time 50 minutes

Ingredients
 

  • 4 large Russet potatoes
  • 1/4 cup olive oil
  • 1 tablespoon salt

Instructions
 

  • Preheat the oven to 425ºF.
  • Wash and dry the potatoes.
  • Pierce the potato 2-3 times with a fork (See notes in article above!)
  • Rub oil all over the potatoes (or choose one of the other options above to rub on the outside).
  • Rub salt all over the potatoes. We prefer coarse sea salt or pink himalayan salt.
  • Place the potatoes on a baking sheet and bake for about 45 minutes.
  • The exact baking time will depend on how large the potatoes are. The potato should be tender inside if you poke a fork into it.
  • Serve with butter, cheese, chives, sour cream and all of your favorite toppings!

Video

Notes

The calories shown are based on one potato with no toppings, but all potatoes are a different size. To get an exact calorie count,  weigh the potato and search google for the amount of calories that size potato.  Since different brands of ingredients have different nutritional information, the calories shown are just an estimate. **We are not dietitians and recommend you seek a nutritionist for exact nutritional information.**

Nutrition

Calories: 410kcal | Carbohydrates: 66g | Protein: 7g | Fat: 13g | Saturated Fat: 1g | Sodium: 1762mg | Potassium: 1538mg | Fiber: 4g | Sugar: 2g | Vitamin C: 21mg | Calcium: 48mg | Iron: 3.3mg
Course Side Dish
Cuisine American
Calories 410
Keyword best baked potatoes, perfect baked potatoes

Baked Potato Toppings

Loaded baked potato bars are a fun idea for a party. Here’s some toppings ideas other than traditional cheese, sour cream and onions:

Other Potato Recipes

Find a new potato recipe to love:

Serve these classic potatoes alongside our favorite corn dish for a delicious meal.

About Julie Clark

I'm Julie Clark, CEO and recipe developer of Tastes of Lizzy T. With my B.A. in Education and over 30 years of cooking and baking, I want to teach YOU the best of our family recipes.

Get 5 Classic Recipes with a Deliciously Secret Twist

You might also like

Join the Discussion

Comments

  1. 5 stars
    Made it according to recipe. I decided to poke with a fork once or twice. I turned them halfway through cooking time. Then I poked other side once. They were delicious. You could smell and taste the olive oil…Excellent!!

  2. 5 stars
    Seriously the best baked potato ever! I just place ours on the rack with baking sheet under it, but they’re incredible! Himalayan pink salt is a must 👏🏼

  3. I made these on a gas grill, using indirect heat. I prepared the potatoes as directed and placed them into a grill-friendly pan for about 45-minutes. The potato skin was nicely dry and slightly crispy. The best was the actual potato. They were so creamy! I put a small amount of butter and sour cream on top, but honestly didn’t need the sour cream.

  4. 5 stars
    Wow, your recipe is so awesome. I have never known this recipe. Thanks for sharing. I will try to follow your recipe and I hope it looks delicious as your picture. I will share this recipe for my friends and my family. I think they love it too.

  5. Look yummy! One of my favorite baked potatoes, nice to see your recipe, easy to follow, will cook this for family this weekend. Thank you!

  6. 5 stars
    I didn’t use exact measurements, and I used 6 Russet Potatoes. I coated them in Olive Oil and fine sea salt. The potatoes took about 2 hours to fully cook through, and they were by far the best baked potatoes that I ever had! This time around, I ate them with sour cream and chives. Thank you for this recipe. I’ll be using it again.

  7. 5 stars
    We loved your recipe! They were so good and we all ate the skin because it was so flavorful and delicious!

    Do you know if these can be cooked in an air fryer?

  8. The flash point of olive oil is around 400 degrees, isnt this dangerous? I dont want to set my stove on fire?

    1. We’ve never had an issue, but of course you can use whatever type of oil you’d like if you’re unsure.

  9. 5 stars
    The only time we wrapped baked potatoes in foil was after baking to keep them hot and fresh. Cooking a foil-wrapped potato results in a steamed potato.

  10. 5 stars
    I just bought some HUGE russet potatoes on a whim to bake. Went online to double check temp. I inserted steel rods – usually reserved for bbq skewers (because my mom told me years ago that it helped cut back on baking time). After reading some of the counts, I really went out on a limb and smeared mine with truffle oil and Montreal seasoning. OMG! They have only been in over 30 min now, the house smells great and my husband can’t wait! P.S. American Heart Assoc says stay away fr Coconut oil for cooking, and just apply it to your skin♥️

  11. 5 stars
    My family loves the taste of these potatoes so much it is now in our regular dinner menu. We add avocados (and ,or guacamole) salsa, shredded cheese and whatever else you can think of and have just potatoes and mega fixings for dinner!

  12. 5 stars
    As a potato lover, I’m not sure why anyone would ever try oven baked potatoes anywhere else!

  13. 5 stars
    Wife and I love this recipe. We will never use the foil method again, the skin comes out crispy and tasteing great. We use Montreal Steak Seasoning instead of salt.

See More Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe Rating